Paragraph symbol and the letters “AI” against a digital background of binary code, symbolising AI-assisted law-making and the machine-readable processing of legal norms.photoschmidt/Adobe Stock

The transformation of law-making through AI-assisted processing of legal norms and the "Law as Code" principle

sprungmarken_marker_5303

Thematic background

AI-supported legislative drafting and the ‘Law as Code’ principle represent new approaches to developing, structuring, and digitally implementing legal provisions. These approaches are expected to make law-making and administrative implementation more efficient, consistent, transparent and compatible with digital administration.

While AI tools can support the analysis, structuring and drafting of legal provisions, 'Law as Code' seeks to create machine-readable, visualised and, in some cases, executable representations of legal rules. Consequently, the focus shifts from the digitisation of existing procedures to the technical processing of legal provisions themselves.

Various approaches to supporting legislative processes through AI applications or converting statutory provisions into machine-readable formats are already being tested in several countries. To date, limited attention has been paid to the implications of AI tools and the ‘Law as Code’ principle for both law-making and the application of law in administrative practice.

. Their use raises new legal, technical and political questions, particularly regarding transparency, traceability and democratic legitimacy.

The transition from legal text to machine-readable representations is therefore more than a mere change in format. It is a significant legal and political process that shapes the law. Therefore, it is becoming increasingly important to consider what potential and limitations AI-supporte d legislative drafting and the ‘Law as Code’ principle hold for German legislation, and what conditions must be established for their responsible use.

Objectives and approach

This TA-Kompakt project examines the current state of development and potential applications of AI-supported legislative drafting and ‘Law as Code’ in the German law-making. It assesses the associated opportunities and challenges, and derives policy options for policymakers and public administration.

The analysis is guided by the following questions:

  1. Which technical approaches to AI-supported legislative drafting and 'Law as Code' are already in use or currently being developed?
  2. What potential benefits and limitations arise in terms of the quality, transparency, traceability, and democratic legitimacy of legislative processes?
  3. What requirements must machine-readable or executable legal provisions fulfil in order to be used legally and transparently in law-making and administrative implementation?
  4. What opportunities and challenges does the 'Law as Code' principle present in law-making and administrative implementation?
  5. What policy options can be derived to ensure the responsible, public interest-oriented use of these technologies?

The project includes a review of the scientific and policy literature, an analysis of current developments and international examples, expert interviews, as well as the examination of an illustrative use case. The findings are synthesised, assessed and presented in a TA-Kompakt report.

Previous publications on this topic


Legal Tech. TAB-Fokus
Kind, S.; Ferdinand, J.-P.; Priesack, K.
2019, June. Büro für Technikfolgen-Abschätzung beim Deutschen Bundestag (TAB) Full textFull text of the publication as PDF document 
Legal Tech – Potenziale und Wirkungen. TA-Vorstudie
Kind, S.; Ferdinand, J.-P.; Priesack, K.
2019. Büro für Technikfolgen-Abschätzung beim Deutschen Bundestag (TAB). doi:10.5445/IR/1000131254 Full textFull text of the publication as PDF document